绿鳍马面鲀海捕群体与养殖群体的形态差异分析

Morphological difference analysis between wild-caught and farmed populations of Thamnaconus septentrionalis

  • 摘要: 【目的】 探明绿鳍马面鲀海捕群体与养殖群体的形态差异,建立高效识别方法,为绿鳍马面鲀种质资源保护与可持续利用提供理论依据。【方法】 采用传统形态学与基于地标点的几何形态学测量方法,对采自山东青岛和浙江舟山的海捕群体、山东烟台和江苏连云港的养殖群体共120尾绿鳍马面鲀样本进行形态差异分析。【结果】 传统形态学分析结果显示,4个群体28个形态可量比例性状均存在明显差异,主成分分析共提取了8个主成分,累计贡献率达81.37%,各群体散点分布存在重叠;聚类分析结果显示,青岛和舟山海捕群体形态最接近,连云港养殖群体与其他群体距离最远;交叉验证判别准确率和逐步判别准确率分别为90.00%和83.33%。几何形态学分析结果显示,基于14个地标点提取的6个主成分累计贡献率达84.11%;第一典型变量和第二典型变量的累计贡献率达94.12%;主成分分析结果显示,连云港养殖群体与其他群体区分较明显,烟台养殖群体与海捕群体重叠较多,但整体区分效果较传统形态学更清晰;2个海捕群体间马氏距离与普氏距离最短;综合判别准确率与交叉验证判别准确率分别提升至93.33%和89.17%。薄板样条分析结果显示,海捕群体与养殖群体的形态差异集中于头部、躯干中前部及尾部,其中连云港养殖群体趋异性最大,2个海捕群体虽形态趋同但变异部位呈多态性分布。【结论】 绿鳍马面鲀海捕与养殖群体在头部、躯干中前部及尾部存在形态分化,这种分化是自然水域复杂环境因子(水流、摄食等)与养殖环境及人工定向选育综合作用的表型响应。几何形态学方法在识别细微形态变异与可视化方面具有独特优势,可作为鉴别群体、评估种质资源差异的精准工具。

     

    Abstract: 【Objective】 This study aimed to elucidate the morphological differences between wild-caught and farmed populations of Thamnaconus septentrionalis and establish an efficient identification method, providing theoretical basis for conservation and sustainable utilization of Thamnaconus septentrionalis germplasm resources. 【Method】 The traditional morphological method and geometric morphometric method based on landmark points were used to analyze the morphological differences of 120 Thamnaconus septentrionalis samples of wild-caught populations in Qingdao, Shandong and Zhoushan, Zhejiang, and farmed populations in Yantai, Shandong and Lianyungang, Jiangsu. 【Result】 The traditional morphological analysis showed that there were marked differences in 28 measurable proportional morphological traits among the 4 populations. Principal component analysis extracted 8 principal components with a cumulative contribution rate of 81.37%, and the scatter plots of the populations overlapped. Cluster analysis showed that the wild-caught populations from Qingdao and Zhoushan were the most similar in morphology, while the farmed population from Lianyungang was the most distant from the others. The cross-validation discrimination accuracy and stepwise discriminanation accuracy were 90.00% and 83.33% respectively. The geometric morphometric analysis showed that the cumulative contribution rate of the 6 principal components extracted based on 14 landmark points was 84.11%, and the cumulative contribution rate of the first and second canonical variables was 94.12%. The principal component analysis results indicated that the farmed population from Lianyungang was more distinct from the others, while the farmed population from Yantai overlapped more with the wild-caught populations, but the overall discrimination effect was clearer than that of traditional morphology. The Mahalanobis distance and Procrustes distance between the two wild-caught populations were the shortest. The comprehensive discrimination accuracy and cross-validation discriminantion accuracy were increased to 93.33% and 89.17% respectively. The thin-plate spline analysis showed that the morphological differences between wild-caught and farmed populations were concentrated in the head, the anterior and middle part of the trunk, and the tail. Among them, the farmed population in Lianyungang had the greatest divergence, and although the two wild-caught populations were morphologically similar, the variation parts were polymorphically distributed. 【Conclusion】 Morphological differentiation is found in the head, the anterior and middle part of the trunk, and the tail between wild-caught and farmed Thamnaconus septentrionalis populations. Such differentiation is a phenotypic response to the combined effects of complex environmental factors in natural waters (such as water flow and feeding), the farmed environment, and artificial directional selection. Geometric morphometric methods have unique advantages in identifying subtle morphological variations and visualization, and can be used as a precise tool for identifying populations and assessing the differences in germplasm resources.

     

/

返回文章
返回